Why Devin Booker and the Phoenix Suns Struggle Without Kevin Durant and Bradley Beal

The Phoenix Suns entered the 2023-24 NBA season with sky-high expectations after assembling a star-studded trio of Devin Booker, Kevin Durant, and Bradley Beal. With championship aspirations and one of the league’s most potent offensive lineups on paper, the Suns appeared poised to dominate. However, injuries to Durant and Beal have left Booker to shoulder the load, and the Suns have struggled to find consistent success without their other two stars.

This raises a pressing question: why are the Suns unable to win consistently when Booker is left to lead the charge solo? A closer look reveals several key factors contributing to the team’s struggles.

1. Heavy Reliance on Star Power

The Suns’ roster construction heavily leans on their “Big Three,” which means when two-thirds of that equation are missing, the team lacks the firepower to compete with top-tier opponents. While Booker is an elite scorer and playmaker, he cannot replicate the combined offensive production and floor-spacing that Durant and Beal bring to the table.

Durant is one of the greatest scorers in NBA history, capable of shooting over any defender, while Beal is a prolific three-level scorer who adds another dimension to the offense. Without these two, opposing teams can key in on Booker, throwing double teams and forcing other players to step up.

This heavy reliance on stars was evident in the Suns’ recent losses, where Booker faced relentless defensive pressure and lacked consistent support from his teammates.

2. Lack of Depth

One of the trade-offs for acquiring stars like Durant and Beal is the depletion of roster depth. To assemble their superstar trio, the Suns sacrificed key role players, leaving their bench thin and inexperienced. While players like Eric Gordon, Grayson Allen, and Jusuf Nurkic have provided moments of brilliance, the supporting cast has struggled to maintain consistency, especially when asked to play extended minutes.

The lack of reliable scoring options beyond Booker has been a glaring issue. Without Durant and Beal, the Suns have often looked stagnant on offense, relying too much on Booker to create shots or facilitate plays. This lack of depth becomes even more problematic in crunch-time situations when defenses tighten up.

3. Defensive Challenges

In addition to their offensive struggles, the Suns’ defense has been inconsistent. Durant’s length and defensive versatility are sorely missed, as he provides rim protection and the ability to guard multiple positions. Similarly, Beal’s athleticism allows him to contest perimeter shots and disrupt passing lanes.

Without these two, the Suns’ defense has been vulnerable, particularly against high-scoring teams. Booker, while a capable defender, cannot cover for the defensive shortcomings of the entire team. Nurkic, the team’s primary big man, has struggled with mobility, leaving the Suns exposed in pick-and-roll situations.

4. Fatigue and Overload on Devin Booker

Booker’s talent is undeniable, but he is being asked to do too much in Durant and Beal’s absence. He’s not only tasked with scoring but also facilitating the offense, often acting as the primary ball-handler. This dual responsibility can lead to fatigue, particularly in games where he’s playing 35-40 minutes.

Booker’s increased workload has also made him more prone to turnovers, as defenses focus on disrupting his rhythm. While he has delivered impressive individual performances, including multiple 30-point games, basketball is a team sport, and no player can carry a team single-handedly for an extended period.

5. Chemistry Still in Development

The Suns’ struggles without Durant and Beal also highlight a broader issue: the team is still figuring out its identity. The “Big Three” has had limited time to develop chemistry due to injuries, and the rest of the roster is adjusting to new roles and expectations.

Without Durant and Beal, players like Gordon, Allen, and Nurkic are thrust into unfamiliar roles, leading to disjointed play. The lack of continuity has made it difficult for the team to establish a consistent rhythm, both offensively and defensively.

6. Tough Schedule

The Suns have faced a challenging schedule early in the season, with matchups against strong opponents. Missing two All-Stars has made it even harder to compete in a Western Conference loaded with talent. Teams like the Denver Nuggets, Golden State Warriors, and Dallas Mavericks have exploited the Suns’ vulnerabilities, exposing their reliance on star players.

What Needs to Change?

To address their struggles, the Suns must make adjustments while waiting for Durant and Beal to return:

Prioritize Depth Development
Head coach Frank Vogel should experiment with rotations to identify reliable contributors off the bench. Players like Jordan Goodwin and Keita Bates-Diop must step up and provide consistent production.
Shift Focus to Defense
With scoring harder to come by, the Suns need to tighten their defense to stay competitive in games. Improved communication and effort on the defensive end can help compensate for their offensive shortcomings.
Reduce Booker’s Workload
Vogel must find ways to lighten Booker’s burden, whether by utilizing Gordon and Allen as secondary playmakers or running more off-ball sets to free him up for easier looks.
Stay Patient
The Suns need to weather this storm and avoid making knee-jerk reactions. Once Durant and Beal return, the team’s dynamic will shift significantly, and they will likely become the offensive juggernaut they were expected to be.

Conclusion

The Phoenix Suns’ struggles without Kevin Durant and Bradley Beal underscore the challenges of building a star-heavy roster. While Devin Booker has been exceptional, basketball is a team sport, and the lack of depth and defensive consistency has made it difficult for the Suns to find success.

However, there is reason for optimism. Durant and Beal’s eventual return will restore balance to the team, and Booker’s resilience during this stretch demonstrates his leadership and commitment to winning.

The Suns’ early-season adversity could ultimately serve as a valuable learning experience, preparing them for the challenges of a long NBA season. If they can stay afloat until their stars return, the Suns will remain a formidable contender in the Western Conference. For now, it’s all about survival and growth in the face of adversity.

4o